Bansal, P. (Tima), & Corley, K. (2012). Publishing in AMJ —Part 7: What’s Different about Qualitative Research? Academy of Management Journal, 55(3), 509–513. https://doi.org/10.5465/amj.2012.4003
Purpose of the Research
📌 What is this study about? This paper by Bansal & Corley (2012) provides insights into what makes qualitative research unique and how to successfully publish it in the Academy of Management Journal (AMJ). The authors synthesize insights from top qualitative researchers and reviewers to highlight the differences between qualitative and quantitative research and provide guidance for crafting strong qualitative manuscripts.
📌 Key Topics Covered:
- How qualitative research builds theory inductively
- How to craft a compelling introduction and discussion
- Why qualitative research must tell a strong story
- The importance of transparency in qualitative methods
- How qualitative research embraces an iterative process
📌 Why does it matter? Many scholars, particularly those trained in quantitative research, struggle to understand how to frame and present qualitative work. This paper clarifies key expectations and best practices for qualitative research in top-tier journals like AMJ.
📌 Citation: Bansal, P., & Corley, K. (2012). Publishing in AMJ—Part 7: What’s Different About Qualitative Research? Academy of Management Journal, 55(3), 509–513.
Key Differences Between Qualitative & Quantitative Research
📌 Step 1: Building Theory Inductively Unlike quantitative research, which typically tests hypotheses based on existing theories, qualitative research builds theory from data. The goal is to identify new patterns and develop theoretical insights rather than confirm what is already known.
📌 Step 2: Crafting the Front End of a Qualitative Paper
- The introduction must clearly define the research gap and motivate why the study is important.
- Unlike quantitative papers, qualitative papers have a shorter literature review but still need to position the research question within an existing theoretical conversation.
- If the literature review reveals too much, readers may feel the theory did not emerge from the data.
📌 Step 3: Developing a Robust Discussion Section
- Quantitative papers: Theoretical contributions are often built at the front through hypotheses, while the discussion interprets results.
- Qualitative papers: The discussion is where the major theoretical punch happens, as the new theory is woven together from data and analysis.
- The discussion must clearly connect findings to theory while showing how the study advances prior research.
How the Research Was Conducted
📋 Step 4: Gathering Expert Insights
- The authors surveyed 24 qualitative researchers and reviewers who regularly publish in AMJ.
- They synthesized common themes and key lessons learned from these experts.
- The insights were further compared against 180 editorial decisions the authors made as AMJ associate editors for qualitative manuscripts.
📌 Step 5: Identifying Common Challenges in Qualitative Research
- Lack of methodological transparency: Many qualitative papers do not clearly explain how data were collected and analyzed.
- Weak theoretical grounding: Some manuscripts fail to connect their findings to broader theoretical conversations.
- Poor narrative structure: Unlike quantitative papers, qualitative research must tell a compelling story that integrates data and theory.
📞 Step 6: Emphasizing Transparent Methods
- Qualitative researchers have more flexibility in methodology, but this means they must provide detailed accounts of their data collection and analysis process.
- Methods should describe the researcher’s journey and explain how emergent theory was developed from the data.
📌 Step 7: Using Creative Data Displays
- Unlike quantitative research, which often relies on statistical tables, qualitative papers require innovative ways to present data.
- Best practices:
- Use chronological event maps to show how processes unfolded.
- Organize data by themes and categories to make patterns clear.
- Use quotes and detailed narratives to bring findings to life.
Key Findings & Insights
🧠 Qualitative Research Tells a Story
- Over 50% of the researchers surveyed emphasized the importance of storytelling in qualitative research.
- A strong qualitative paper is structured like a narrative, where theory and data unfold together to create a compelling argument.
💡 Theoretical Contribution Happens at the End
- Unlike quantitative research, which states hypotheses upfront, qualitative research builds theory as part of the discussion.
- The best qualitative papers show how new insights emerged from the data rather than forcing data to fit existing theory.
📊 Qualitative Research is Iterative
- Data collection and analysis occur simultaneously, allowing for constant refinement of insights.
- Writing is part of the research process—new ideas often emerge as the paper is being written.
Why This Research is Important
✅ Clarifies how to publish qualitative research in top journals 📊 (helps qualitative researchers structure their papers effectively) ✅ Highlights the differences between qualitative & quantitative approaches 🏛 (useful for scholars trained in quantitative methods) ✅ Encourages stronger theoretical contributions 🤯 (pushes qualitative research beyond just “telling stories”) ✅ Provides practical guidance for writing qualitative manuscripts 📚 (ensures methodological transparency and rigor)
Step-by-Step Guide to Writing a Strong Qualitative Paper
1️⃣ Clearly define the research gap – Why is this study important? 2️⃣ Use a concise literature review – Position the research without over-explaining existing theories. 3️⃣ Describe the methodology transparently – Explain how data were collected and analyzed. 4️⃣ Develop a strong discussion section – Theoretical contributions should emerge from data, not be pre-defined. 5️⃣ Use creative data displays – Show, don’t just tell. 6️⃣ Tell a compelling story – Weave theory and data together. 7️⃣ Embrace the iterative process – Writing and analysis should evolve together.
Conclusion: Publishing Strong Qualitative Research
📌 Qualitative research is not just about collecting data—it’s about crafting a compelling theoretical contribution. 📌 Successful qualitative papers require methodological transparency and strong storytelling. 📌 Researchers must embrace the iterative nature of qualitative inquiry and refine their work throughout the writing process.
Final Thought: By following these principles, qualitative researchers can enhance the impact of their work and improve their chances of publishing in top-tier journals like AMJ. 📖✨
Leave a Reply